If I Were A Carpenter









Carpenters fandom is no longer the Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name




If I Were a Carpenter CD Cover Thanks to a passel of bands - Redd Kross, Sonic Youth and Bettie Serveert among them - Carpenters fandom is no longer the Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name. If I Were a Carpenter features a surprisingly hip line-up of acts that march proudly, arms linked, out of the Carpenters closet in a tribute to the beloved duo. With standards like "Goodbye to Love", "Solitaire" and "Rainy Days and Mondays' covered by American Music Club, Sheryl Crow and Cracker, it will finally be proven that it's not just easy listeners whose lips quiver uncontrollably when they hear "Close to You".

Producers Matt Wallace (Paul Westerberg, Faith No More) and David Konjoyan (rock scribe), felt that pairing the Carpenters' smooth pop with rock acts would be a kick. Things had the potential to get ugly, though, when musicians had to lobby for songs, resulting in a skirmish over rights to, for instance, "Superstar". But when the dust settled, everyone was satisfied. "We got a list, and "We've Only Just Begun" was still on there," says Grant Lee Buffalo's Grant Lee Phillips. "It seemed like the quintessential Carpenters song, I always saw the darker side of what they did. My mom had a Camaro, and we had an 8-track of the Carpenters. It's in my blood."

Richard Carpenter may not agree with Phillips' assessment but has joined in on the fun nonetheless, playing keyboards and singing back-up for Matthew Sweet on "Let Me Be the One." Most songs, however, have a distinctly un-Carpenters spin. "I'm most flattered by this (record)," says Carpenter. "And I know Karen would be, too."

- R O L L I N G    S T O N E

If I Were A Carpenter

  1. American Music Club - Goodbye to Love
  2. Shonen Knife - Top of the World
  3. Sonic Youth - Superstar
  4. The Cranberries - Close to You
  5. Bettie Serveert - For All We Know
  6. Dishwalla - It's Going to Take Some Time
  7. Sheryl Crow - Solitaire
  8. Johnette Napolitano/Marc Moreland - Hurting Each Other
  9. Redd Kross - Yesterday Once More
  10. Babes in Toyland - Calling Occupants of Interplanetary Craft
  11. Cracker - Rainy Days and Mondays
  12. Matthew Sweet - Let Me Be the One
  13. 4 Non-Blonds - Bless the Beasts and Children
  14. Grant Lee Buffalo - We've Only Just Begun

1994

Return to DISCOGRAPHY

Return To CARPENTERS PAGE

Created - 5 May 1997